This one may be a little rough to read as I am going to try to do four beer reviews in one post. I did not even know that these beers existed before Gregg offered me some bottles to evaluate, so I was curious to see how they tasted. Though I only had them that one time, they turned out to be not that bad all in all. Hopefully this rundown of the four with shorter reviews for each will make some sense.
For a Saturday set of reviews . . .
Brewery: Kirkland Signature (Costco) – contract brewed by New Yorker Brewing Co. in Utica, NY which I can only assume is associated with Matt Brewing Company.
Name: Amber Ale (AA) – German Lager (GL) – Pale Ale (PA) – Hefeweizen (H)
Style: American Amber Ale (AA) – German Pilsner (GL) – American Pale Ale (PA) – Weizen (H)
ABV: AA – 5.70%, GL – 5.50%, PA – 5.40%, H – 5.50%,
Tasting Notes: Stored in the fridge and served in a pint glass (AA and PA), pilsner glass (GL), and weizen glass (H).
Aroma: AA – Some malty sweetness, but mild overall. GL – Light graininess, slightly bready, and light overall. PA – Even, fruity hop aroma, and some sweetness. H – Really mild, lightly yeasty/bready nose. Tough to do back to back with really mild aromas.
Appearance: AA – Medium amber color. Slight cream color head with moderate retention and some trail. GL – Golden amber color. Moderate, off-white head with good retention and a heavy trail. PA – Light amber color. Little, off-white head with decent retention and some trail. H – Golden color. Slight cream color head with good retention and a light trail.
Flavor: AA – Low toasted malt flavor and slight bitterness. GL – Slight grainy flavor with low bitterness. Very light overall. PA – Medium, somewhat floral hop flavor with some malty sweetness. H – Some malty flavor with light breadiness. Not what I expected. Difficult back to back with similar flavor profiles among them.
Mouthfeel: AA – Medium body and somewhat creamy with pretty high carbonation. GL – Light body, moderate carbonation, and some crispness/bite. PA – Medium to light body with fairly high carbonation and slightly crisp. H – Light body with lowish carbonation and creamy with a slight bite.
Overall Impressions: AA – Really nice flavor (compared to others). GL – Quite bland but refreshing. PA – Pretty good hop flavors overall. H – Strange to me for style. Not bad and fine for hot weather backyard grilling, but certainly nothing special. I do not know cost but I am sure it is likely a great value for what they are.
Grade: Probably start at B- and work down.
Ranking the four (best first):
- Me – AA, PA, H, and GL
- The Wife – H, AA, GL, PA

Not sure where the review picture is, but here is proof they were spending time with our broccoli.








What Others Say