If the weather is hot and sunny it must be summer already, right?  Maybe not, though it sure has felt like it the last handful of days here in Central Florida.  With the weather pretending to be summer it made sense to post another beer review in honor of that season, despite it only being April.

There is also something with this one that I notice from time to time when looking back over reviews done many months ago.  After reading the notes that I took while drinking it, I am a bit confused by the final grade that I gave it.  It makes me wonder what the circumstances were during the evaluation that would have bumped the final grade up a bit.  So for this one I will write the original grade that I wrote down and then also what I would have expected the grade to be only by reading the tasting notes.  That only seems fair.

Brewery: Shipyard Brewing Co. (Portland, ME)

Name: Summer Ale

Style: American Wheat Beer

ABV: 5.1%

Tasting Notes: Stored in the fridge and served in a pint glass.  $8.99 for a six-pack.

Aroma: Moderately strong grainy nose with (seemingly) a slight, spicy hop character somewhere in there.

Appearance: Light golden color.  Two-finger, off-white head with moderate retention and no trail.  Crystal clear with many visible bubbles rising.

Flavor: Medium amount of light grainy, wheaty (surprise, surprise) flavor with a very slight note of hoppiness.  The finish is a bit dry with some sharpness.

Mouthfeel: Light body with a high amount of carbonation that lends some bite (and some of the sharpness at the finish).

Overall Impressions: Crisp and refreshing, though not with a great overall flavor.  It is good for hot weather if served ice cold.

Grade: B (originally written) and C (would have expected)

Did I forget to mention that this picture is lost as well?

The fourth day has finally come and with it the fourth pumpkin beer and the end of this short series of posts.  If you are at all confused, where have you been these last few days?!  Go ahead and check out the entries from Blueprint Brewing, Smuttynose Brewing, and Weyerbacher Brewing to get yourself caught up with the whole pumpkin beers in March thing.

We first heard of this creation when The Wife and I were vacationing with family up in Maine and visited Shipyard Brewing last fall.  At the time the beer was not even available at the brewery because it sold out so fast.  We knew that Shipyard brews were available here in Florida so there was at least a small chance that we would see some on the shelves when arrived back home.  Obviously we got lucky and found a bottle one day without even looking for it.

Be sure to read all the way to the bottom as the long awaited judgment on the flight from The Wife is revealed!

Now to wrap things up . . .

Brewery: Shipyard Brewing Co. (Portland, ME)

Name: Smashed Pumpkin Ale  (Signature Series)

Style: Vegetable Beer

ABV: 9.0%

Tasting Notes: Stored in the wine fridge (51 degrees +/-) and served in a pint glass.  $8.99 for 1pt. 6oz.

Aroma: Low, but prominent pumpkin spice aroma (mostly nutmeg to me) and a clean aroma overall.

Appearance: Amber in color with a slight orange/copper hue.  Slight dark(er) cream head that quickly dissipates with no trail.  Crystal clear with few rising bubbles visible.

Flavor: The pumpkin spice flavors are prominent with a sugary sweetness underneath.  The spiciness carries through to the finish and lingers slightly.  Really full flavor overall that is like liquid pumpkin pie.

Mouthfeel: Medium body with low(ish) carbonation.  A low amount of warmth is noticeable.

Overall Impressions: Most pumpkiny pumpkin ale that I have tried (to date) and is definitely at the top of the Shipyard family for me.  The aroma really carries through to the flavor.  Fitting/appropriate for the holidays (Thanksgiving or Christmas).

Grade: A

4240767145 47dd924a0c Shipyard Brewing Co.   Smashed Pumpkin Ale

Her final decisions have been made . . . read below.

As for the final rankings from The Wife and her blind tasting:

  1. Shipyard Smashed Pumpkin Ale (very close 1st and 2nd)
  2. Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale (very close 1st and 2nd)
  3. Blueprint Gourdeous One
  4. Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale (distant 4th)

She fell right in line with the final grades that I had when drinking the four of them side by side.  I don’t know that it means we are correct, but I now know what to look for on the shelves and what to brew at home next fall.

Cheers!

I have tentative plans to visit the Shipyard Brewing Company’s brewery when I am passing through Portland next month because I generally enjoy and appreciate their beers.  This one was an exception to that general enjoyment for me.  Maybe I had set my expectations too high and it fell short, but in the end it wasn’t a beer that I needed to have again anytime soon.

Brewery: Shipyard Brewing Company (Portland, Maine)

Name: Chamberlain Pale Ale

Style: Pale Ale (American)

ABV: 4.9%

Tasting Notes: Stored in the fridge and served in a pint glass.  $3.99 for 22oz

Aroma: Light, slightly earthy hop nose.  Very faint caramel aroma?

Appearance: Light copper color with orange tint.  Short, off-white head that dissipates quickly without a trail.  Very clear with a few rising bubbles visible.

Flavor: Low hop flavor with a slight earthiness.  Minerally finish with some cloying.  Maybe a hint of a bready malt flavor?  The aroma was a bit stronger than the flavor turned out to be.

Mouthfeel: Light body with some dryness on the palate.  Medium to high carbonation, producing some bite (sharpness).

Overall Impressions: Weak overall aroma and flavor (compared to what I expect in an APA).  Alcohol content typical for style.  Really not much going on overall.  Drinkable, but also forgettable.

Grade: C to C-

Shipyard Brewing Co. - Chamberlain Pale Ale

Shipyard Brewing Co. - Chamberlain Pale Ale

© 2010 A Night With The Hops "He was a wise man who invented beer." - Plato Suffusion WordPress theme by Sayontan Sinha